John Mullins, CEO

Hello Everyone!

We are so happy you decided to check us out, let me tell you about our passion : Feeding America!

Wondering if there is a more affordable, all-natural option towards feeding your family?
Founded in 2011 by John Mullins, America’s Choice Gourmet was built on a commitment to excellence — sourcing USDA Prime and premium-quality meats with uncompromising standards.
What began as a respected wholesale operation serving select clients across North Carolina has evolved into one of Wilmington’s premier destinations for exceptional meats.
In 2013, Cynthia Herrera joined the company as Vice President and business partner, bringing strategic vision, elevated customer experience, and a deep passion for culinary culture. Originally from Buenos Aires — renowned for its world-class beef — Cynthia blends heritage, innovation, and hospitality into the fabric of the brand
During the pandemic, as families sought dependable access to high-quality food, America’s Choice Gourmet expanded its retail presence to better serve the community. Demand quickly grew — with loyal customers lining up at the Northchase location — affirming the company’s reputation for quality and trust.
Continued customer relationships inspired the opening of a second storefront at 4716 Carolina Beach Road — made possible in part by a devoted client who believed strongly enough in the brand to offer their own premises for the expansion. A testament to the loyalty and confidence the company has cultivated.
Today, America’s Choice Gourmet proudly operates two Wilmington locations:
• 4510 Northchase Parkway NE — led by John Mullins
• 4716 Carolina Beach Road — led by Cynthia Herrera
Together, they curate an extensive selection of USDA Prime beef, premium poultry, seafood, pork, and over 50+ exotic meats — offering wholesale-level sourcing with boutique-level service.
America’s Choice Gourmet is defined by refinement, integrity, and a dedication to nourishing families with distinction.
Experience the standard.
America’s Choice Gourmet.
Let’s Meat.
We established our company as a less expensive alternative to grocery stores, and a healthier alternative to competing wholesale companies

We want to bring your groceries to you, and by doing this, we enhance your shopping experience, imagine : a free regional home delivery service !

At America’s Choice Gourmet, we realize that the best way to grow our business is through your grilling adventures to come and share!

Provide our customers with the best experience, and reward them for spreading the word. Remember our “Steak-to-Mouth” advertising!

From this ideal, we set up our referral based growth system, which offers free food to those who share our name with family and friends, neighbors and co-workers.

Why Prime Beef?

At America’s Choice Gourmet, we sell USDA choice and prime beef

You get real food, and nothing but the food when you shop with us.

LEARN MORE